Top 48 Catcher Rankings For The 2025 Fantasy Baseball Season

A deep dive into my catcher rankings for the 2025 season including a tier by tier breakdown at the end

One big thing I wanted to keep you guys up to date with on the substack is my rankings. I’m lucky enough to be a part of the FantasyPros Expert Rankings Committee and I do my best to keep my rankings updated throughout the season.

To make it easier to manage and easier to digest as a reader I’m going to be updating them position by position and posting them on the stack. I’ll follow it up with my Top-300 rankings as well.

At the end of each position rankings article I’ll have a breakdown of a handful of guys in each tier and why I have them ranked where they’re at. Just to help give a bit more insight.

Rankings outside of the top 10 and the full insight breakdown will be for paid subs only, so if you’re interested in more it’s only $5/month for everything! The same amount you spent on your coffee this morning. I hope you guys enjoy!

2025 Fantasy Baseball Catcher Rankings

Tier 1

• 1

  William Contreras, MIL

• 2

  Cal Raleigh, SEA

• 3

  Adley Rutschman, BAL

Tier 2

• 4

  Salvador Perez, KC

• 5

  Will Smith, LAD

• 6

  Yainer Diaz, HOU

• 7

  Francisco Alvarez, NYM

Tier 3

• 8

  Shea Langeliers, ATH

• 9

  Tyler Stephenson, CIN

• 10

  Willson Contreras, STL